Herman The German Friendship Cake – Dealing With Intolerances

Dealing with food intolerance.

I was recently presented with the active starter mix for a Herman the German Friendship Cake.  I suffer gluten and dairy intolerances and had to consider this without demonstrating an unfriendly attitude and wondered what would be the outcome if I continued the process without adding gluten and dairy.

On days four and nine I substituted Dove’s plain gluten free flour mix and soya milk (I used the light/unsweetened variety).  The mixture did not die on me so I prepared to continue.  However, I was disinclined to pass on live mix since I was not sure that the substitution would work, but I was reluctant to give up.  I decided to produce four cakes and pass baked cakes on instead.

On day ten I used Dove’s plain gluten free flour mix with a gluten free baking powder.  The remaining cake ingredients did not breach gluten and dairy free requirements but I did have to omit the melted butter and sugar topping.

I am attaching photograph of the baked cakes.  All cakes took much longer than the recommended baking time.  The smallest cake took about 65 minutes and the largest (square) was close to 100 minutes.  I gave away three cakes but had an opportunity of sampling two out of the four baked cakes – the proof of the pudding being in the eating!

The cakes were well risen, light, moist and enjoyable.  The only problem encountered was when cutting – the centre was inclined towards crumbling.  Generally speaking, I would say that the substitution of gluten and dairy free products was a success.  Crumbling often occurs when substituting gluten free flour.  This can be improved (if not overcome) by the use of Xantham Gum;  unfortunately I forgot to add this vital ingredient to mine!  I recommend 2 teaspoons of Xanthan Gum to every 500 grams of gluten free flour (this is a trial and error component – as most people familiar with gluten free baking will appreciate).

Finally, there are many levels of intolerance (allergies, Celiac Disease etc.) and sufferers will understand their own level.  On a personal basis I considered that gluten and dairy from the original starter was diluted sufficiently for me by the volume of additional ingredients – others must base their decision upon their own known level of intolerance.

by Doreen Essex

5 Comments on Herman The German Friendship Cake – Dealing With Intolerances

  1. grace // 25/06/2012 at 09:10 //

    I’m personally inclined to begin a dairy/gluten free batch from the start, as I would be very unhappy to be told a cake was ok for me, to discover that it contained “watered down” dairy- which would still make me ill! It’s probably worth making it from scratch, and then sending it out with revised instructions!

  2. Darren // 26/07/2012 at 18:32 //

    Many thanks for sharing your experience with Gluten-Free ingredients.
    I am going to give it a go

    • I was recently given this book by my ceilac mother-in-law, and I am so grateful. My sister and I are both ceilacs, and desserts like cake and cookies have been missing from our lives for years. (I mean, REAL cakes and cookies that taste like their gluten-laiden counterparts.) From the very first recipe we tried- frosted macadamia nut bars (p.145) to my 25th birthday treat- whoopie pies (p.118), my entire family has devoured the outcomes. Including those who can eat wheat. This book explains evey detail about gluten-free flours, right down to thier protein contents, and how and why they work. This is an absolute must for anyone who wants to enter back into the realm of heavenly desserts, or anyone catering to their beloved ceilac. Just be prepared to stock your shelves with a bunch of new flours, and you’ll be on your way!

  3. Kitty Rose // 13/01/2013 at 16:31 //

    I’ve received a gluten free starter today. It has been fed with G/F flour and seems to be ok if a little thin. I shall also be using G/F flour to feed my Herman. Will let you know how it turns out. 🙂

    • Stuart // 13/01/2013 at 19:37 //

      Hi Kitty,

      Definitely get in touch and let me know how your Gluten Free Herman turns out.
      There have been a lot of questions from people with allergies and intolerance to certain food types. If you wanted to do a bit of a write up I could publish it on the website (with a photo or two if you can supply them) and you could help others.

      Do you have a food allergy or intolerance?


Comments are closed.

This site uses cookies. Find out more about this site’s cookies.